(d) The management of Wonderland plc have become concerned about the increased level of operating costsassociated with its petrol-driven ferries and have made a strategic decision to dispose of these. They are nowconsidering entering into a contract with the Newman Steamship Company (NSC), a shipping organisation basedin Robynland. The contract would entail NSC providing transport to and from Cinola Island for all visitors to thezoo and circus.As a result of negotiations with NSC, the directors of Wonderland plc are considering two options whereby NSCwill become responsible for the transportation of visitors to and from Cinola Island with effect from 1 December2007 or 1 December 2008.Additional information is available as follows:(1) NSC would require Wonderland plc to pay for the necessary modifications to their steamships in order thatthey would satisfy marine regulations with regard to passenger transportation. The only firm which couldundertake this work is currently working to full capacity and would require a payment of £2,450,000 inorder to undertake the work necessary so that the ferries could be in operation by 1 December 2007. Thesame firm would require a payment of £1,725,000 in order to make the necessary modifications so thatthe ferries could be in operation by 1 December 2008. The government of Robynland would be willing topay a grant of 8% towards the cost of getting the ferries into operation by 1 December 2007, but would notbe willing to pay a grant in respect of any later date.(2) On 1 December 2002 Wonderland plc paid £500,000 to the Port Licencing Authority of Robynland. Thispayment was for a licence which entitles Wonderland plc to use all harbour facilities in Robynland duringthe five-year period ending 30 November 2007. The licence could be renewed on 1 December 2007 at acost of £150,000 per annum.(3) Redundancy payments would need to be paid in respect of loss of employment. These would amount to£1,200,000 if the contract with NSC commenced on 1 December 2007. This amount would reduce to£750,000 if the contract commenced on 1 December 2008.(4) Wonderland plc has a contract for the provision of petrol for its ferries which is due to expire on 30 November2008. Early termination of the contract would incur a penalty charge of £76,000. An emergency reservestock of petrol held by Wonderland plc, which cannot be used after 30 November 2007 due to marineregulations regarding the age of fuel, could be sold for £55,000 on 1 December 2007 but not on any datethereafter.(5) The ferries could be sold for £3,300,000 on 1 December 2007. If retained after 1 December 2007 theferries would require servicing during the year ending 30 November 2008 which would incur costsamounting to £150,000. The resale value of the ferries on 1 December 2008 would be £2,900,000.(6) Stock of consumable items which originally cost £150,000 could be sold on 1 December 2007 for£110,000 and on 1 December 2008 for £50,000.Required:(i) On purely financial grounds, advise whether the management of Wonderland plc should enter into acontract with NSC with effect from 1 December 2007 or 1 December 2008. You may ignore the timevalue of money. (9 marks)
(d) The management of Wonderland plc have become concerned about the increased level of operating costs
associated with its petrol-driven ferries and have made a strategic decision to dispose of these. They are now
considering entering into a contract with the Newman Steamship Company (NSC), a shipping organisation based
in Robynland. The contract would entail NSC providing transport to and from Cinola Island for all visitors to the
zoo and circus.
As a result of negotiations with NSC, the directors of Wonderland plc are considering two options whereby NSC
will become responsible for the transportation of visitors to and from Cinola Island with effect from 1 December
2007 or 1 December 2008.
Additional information is available as follows:
(1) NSC would require Wonderland plc to pay for the necessary modifications to their steamships in order that
they would satisfy marine regulations with regard to passenger transportation. The only firm which could
undertake this work is currently working to full capacity and would require a payment of £2,450,000 in
order to undertake the work necessary so that the ferries could be in operation by 1 December 2007. The
same firm would require a payment of £1,725,000 in order to make the necessary modifications so that
the ferries could be in operation by 1 December 2008. The government of Robynland would be willing to
pay a grant of 8% towards the cost of getting the ferries into operation by 1 December 2007, but would not
be willing to pay a grant in respect of any later date.
(2) On 1 December 2002 Wonderland plc paid £500,000 to the Port Licencing Authority of Robynland. This
payment was for a licence which entitles Wonderland plc to use all harbour facilities in Robynland during
the five-year period ending 30 November 2007. The licence could be renewed on 1 December 2007 at a
cost of £150,000 per annum.
(3) Redundancy payments would need to be paid in respect of loss of employment. These would amount to
£1,200,000 if the contract with NSC commenced on 1 December 2007. This amount would reduce to
£750,000 if the contract commenced on 1 December 2008.
(4) Wonderland plc has a contract for the provision of petrol for its ferries which is due to expire on 30 November
2008. Early termination of the contract would incur a penalty charge of £76,000. An emergency reserve
stock of petrol held by Wonderland plc, which cannot be used after 30 November 2007 due to marine
regulations regarding the age of fuel, could be sold for £55,000 on 1 December 2007 but not on any date
thereafter.
(5) The ferries could be sold for £3,300,000 on 1 December 2007. If retained after 1 December 2007 the
ferries would require servicing during the year ending 30 November 2008 which would incur costs
amounting to £150,000. The resale value of the ferries on 1 December 2008 would be £2,900,000.
(6) Stock of consumable items which originally cost £150,000 could be sold on 1 December 2007 for
£110,000 and on 1 December 2008 for £50,000.
Required:
(i) On purely financial grounds, advise whether the management of Wonderland plc should enter into a
contract with NSC with effect from 1 December 2007 or 1 December 2008. You may ignore the time
value of money. (9 marks)